When Psyche convinces Cupid to protect college softball pitcher Ellie Beaufort from the other gods, who want to kill her because of a prophecy, he agrees to hide her in his castle. But when his brothers, Phobos and Deimos, discover his secret, he has no choice but to shoot them with his arrows of love.
 
Trapped in a magical castle for six weeks with two gorgeous gods who want nothing more than to love and protect her, Ellie finds herself falling for them both. Phobos and Deimos may be identical ginger twins, but their personalities are vastly different, surprising her in delightful ways. If they succeed in finding a way to be together, against all odds, which will she choose?